Port McNicoll, Tay Real Estate & MLS® Listings

34 active MLS® listings in Tay (Port McNicoll)

461 Barnes Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For saleJust listed

Yesterday

$550K

461 Barnes Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

5 bd2 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by RE/MAX CROSSTOWN REALTY INC.

244/250 Dignard Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For saleJust listed

Yesterday

$555K

244/250 Dignard Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

2 bd1 ba900 ft²

Listed by FARIS TEAM REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE

379 Wardell Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For saleJust listed

5 days ago

$525K

379 Wardell Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

4 bd2 ba900 ft²

Listed by RE/MAX HALLMARK PEGGY HILL GROUP REALTY

278 Woodlands Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For saleJust listed

6 days ago

278 Woodlands Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

0 bd0 ba

Listed by RE/MAX PREMIER INC.

363 Wardell Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

10 days ago

$575K

363 Wardell Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

5 bd2 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by Chase Realty Inc., Brokerage

706 Simcoe Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

12 days ago

$535K

706 Simcoe Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

4 bd2 ba900 ft²

Listed by Keller Williams Experience Realty

475 Athabaska Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

14 days ago

$615K

475 Athabaska Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

4 bd2 ba900 ft²

Listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd

323 BELL Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

14 days ago

$449K

323 BELL Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

753 Fifth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

3 bd3 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by HOME CHOICE REALTY INC.

480 Broderick Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

21 days ago

$670K

480 Broderick Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

5 bd2 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd

For sale

22 days ago

$559K

244/250 Dignard Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

2 bd1 ba900 ft²

Listed by FARIS TEAM REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE

7 Dock Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

26 days ago

$1.70M

7 Dock Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

3 bd3 ba2,250 ft²

Listed by FARIS TEAM REAL ESTATE BROKERAGE

5 Easton Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

34 days ago

$700K

5 Easton Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

3 bd2 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by RE/MAX Georgian Bay Realty Ltd

366 Talbot Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

35 days ago

$135K

366 Talbot Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

3 bd1 ba900 ft²

Listed by SUTTON GROUP INCENTIVE REALTY INC.

196 PARADISE Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

40 days ago

$400K

196 PARADISE Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

2 bd1 ba900 ft²

Listed by ROYAL LEPAGE FIRST CONTACT REALTY

757 Fourth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

42 days ago

$849K

757 Fourth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

7 bd4 ba2,250 ft²

Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

528 First Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

43 days ago

$650K

528 First Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

3 bd2 ba1,300 ft²

Listed by CENTURY 21 B.J. ROTH REALTY LTD.

#40 76 DOCK Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

43 days ago

$800K

#40 76 DOCK Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

0 ba

Listed by CENTURY 21 PERCY FULTON LTD.

679 Simcoe Avenue West, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

56 days ago

$539K

679 Simcoe Avenue West, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

5 bd2 ba900 ft²

Listed by Forest Hill Real Estate Inc.

503 Margaret Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

57 days ago

$130K

503 Margaret Street, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

0 ba350 ft²

Listed by Team Hawke Realty

#Lot 86 548 Fifth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

69 days ago

$80K

#Lot 86 548 Fifth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

0 ba

Listed by ICI SOURCE REAL ASSET SERVICES INC.

817 Eighth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

69 days ago

$369K

817 Eighth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

2 bd1 ba900 ft²

Listed by Re/Max Professionals North

15 Swan Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

72 days ago

$370K

15 Swan Lane, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

0 bd0 ba350 ft²

Listed by HOMELIFE FRONTIER REALTY INC.

770 Fourth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

For sale

98 days ago

$3.49M

770 Fourth Avenue, Tay (Port McNicoll), Ontario, L0K1R0

7 ba

Listed by RIGHT AT HOME REALTY

New listings match this search every day. Get them by email

8 new listings this week

Market overview

Port McNicoll real estate market

Balanced Market

Median list price

$555K

Price per sqft

$495

Active listings

New this week

Avg days on market

—

Median price by type

Houses

$559K

Condos

$2.10M

As of November 2026, homes for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay, Ontario carry a median asking price of about $555,000, across 33 active MLS listings for sale. Asking prices have eased about 14.0% in the past month, giving buyers a little more room than they had earlier in the year. 8 new listings came on this week, and inventory is on the tighter side, so well priced homes tend to attract attention quickly.

That puts Port McNicoll, Tay in the middle of the Ontario market, within reach for move up buyers and growing families. On a per square foot basis, homes here run around $495, a useful benchmark when two listings look similar on paper. Because prices are softening, it is worth comparing recent sales before you make an offer.

Questions

Port McNicoll real estate FAQ

What is the average home price in Port McNicoll?

As of November 2026, the median asking price for a home in Port McNicoll, Tay, Ontario is about $555,000. By property type, houses sit around $559,000 and condos around $2,099,900.

Is Port McNicoll a buyer's or seller's market right now?

Port McNicoll is currently a balanced market, without a strong tilt toward buyers or sellers.

How many homes are for sale in Port McNicoll?

There are currently 33 active MLS listings for sale in Port McNicoll, Tay, Ontario, updated daily on haho.ca.

What are the most popular neighbourhoods in Port McNicoll?

Port McNicoll has a range of established and up and coming neighbourhoods. Use the neighbourhood filters above to compare them by price and inventory.

How long does it take to sell a home in Port McNicoll?

Time to sell in Port McNicoll depends on price and condition. Well priced, move in ready homes tend to sell fastest.

← All neighbourhoods in Tay