$998,500
St. Catharines
58 Ontario Street, St. Catharines (Downtown), Ontario, L2R5J4
This multi-family property in St. Catharines is for sale offering roughly 4,250 sq ft of space. It has been on the market 44 days, fresher than the St. Catharines average of 71 days.
Positioned on a prominent downtown corner, 58 Ontario Street presents a rare opportunity for owner-occupiers, investors, or live-work users to acquire a fully vacant 3,528 sq. ft. architecturally distinctive landmark building with exceptional zoning flexibility (C5-92) in the downtown core. Zoning permits a broad range of residential and commercial uses, allowing the property to function as entirely commercial, entirely residential, or mixed-use, while benefiting from the sought-after downtown parking exemption. Currently configured with a beautifully appointed 1,450 sq. ft. commercial main floor and two self-contained residential apartments above, the property offers three income streams with potential gross annual income of approximately $75,000 based on projected market rents, with additional upside through commercial leasing or owner occupancy. Showcasing original millwork, pocket doors, stained and leaded glass, refinished hardwood flooring, and other period details rarely found in commercial properties today, the building seamlessly combines historic character with modern functionality. Additional features include updated washrooms and kitchens, five ductless splits, full basement storage, separate hydro meters, five on-site parking spaces (2 tandem). Located in the heart of Downtown St. Catharines' heritage district, steps from the Performing Arts Centre, Meridian Centre, Brock University's Marilyn I. Walker School, restaurants and cafés, the area continues to benefit from ongoing residential intensification and commercial reinvestment, supporting long-term demand for both residential and commercial space. (id:66096)
Features and services as supplied by the listing brokerage.
Extended: 44 days on market, against an average age of 71 days across the listings currently for sale in this city
This 5-bed multi-family in St. Catharines (Downtown) has been listed for 44 days, which is 27 days fresher than the city average of 71. Act while there is still low competition.
Approximate location — exact address confirmed upon showing
This home lists at $998,500, about 16.3× the local median household income of $61,200.
Carrying it typically needs a household income of about $195,042 (20% down, 25-yr amortization, stress-tested) — roughly 219% above the area median.
Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census (FSA L2R)
Pick a time that suits you. A verified local agent confirms within 24h.
Loading rates, 30-yr amortization
Cash Needed to Close
Rates via our partner mortgage brokers at iShopRates · Estimates only, not financial advice




Estimate the monthly cashflow if you bought this home as a rental. Every figure below is an editable estimate. This is education only, not financial advice.
Enter the monthly rent you expect, or adjust our estimate.
Enter an estimated monthly rent to see the cashflow.
Estimates only, not a mortgage approval or financial advice. Rate, taxes, and allowances are assumptions you can edit above.