Innisfil Real Estate & MLS® Listings

As of November 2026, homes for sale in Innisfil, Ontario carry a median asking price of about $849,900, across 424 active MLS listings for sale. Asking prices have eased about 12.3% in the past month, giving buyers a little more room than they had earlier in the year. 49 new listings came on this week, and inventory is on the tighter side, so well priced homes tend to attract attention quickly.

That sits above the Ontario median, reflecting steady demand for the area. On a per square foot basis, homes here run around $516, a useful benchmark when two listings look similar on paper. The most active pockets of the Innisfil housing market right now include Alcona, Cookstown, Lefroy, so those are good places to start a search. Because prices are softening, it is worth comparing recent sales before you make an offer.