$2,700,777
Georgian Bay
185 Picnic Island Road, Georgian Bay (Baxter), Ontario, L0K1S0
This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home in Georgian Bay is for sale.
Welcome to 185 Picnic Island Road in Honey Harbour, a rare waterfront opportunity offering over 600 feet of shoreline and spectacular 270-degree sunrise and sunset views across beautiful Georgian Bay. Accessible by deeded road access and located close to Honey Harbour and area marinas, this exceptional property blends privacy, comfort, and year-round enjoyment in a breathtaking natural setting. Designed with quality craftsmanship throughout, the home features 2+ bedrooms and two bathrooms, an open-concept kitchen and dining area complete with propane range, dishwasher, and custom wood cabinetry, along with a bright sunroom and inviting living room with a stone-faced propane fireplace. Pine ceilings, hardwood flooring, and drywall finishes add warmth and character, while in-floor heating and an ICF foundation provide year-round comfort and efficiency. A loft office offers flexible additional space for work or relaxation. Outdoor and accessory features make this property truly exceptional, including two floating docks with hinged ramps and shore decks (8' x 32' and 8' x 30'), a concrete launching ramp, and outstanding workshop space. Above the accessory garage/workshop, a self-contained approximately 420 sq ft in-law suite offers a kitchenette, 3-piece bath, and central vacuum-ideal for guests or extended family. A second accessory workshop (approximately 30' x 38') features three insulated 9-foot garage doors, wood stove heating, and a 70-amp subpanel feed. Additional highlights include a lake water filtration system with UV protection and Pyrotenax heat cable, Cape Cod wood siding, VicWest steel roofing, metal soffit and fascia, and NorthStar windows and doors. A truly unique Georgian Bay property offering lifestyle, functionality, and incredible waterfront living. (id:66096)
Features and services as supplied by the listing brokerage.
Long Listed: 158 days on market, against an average age of 136 days across the listings currently for sale in this city
Homes here sell slower than most markets
Sold homes in this market spent an average of 71 days on the market over the past year, against a median of 48 days across the markets we publish.
Homes here sell below asking price
Homes in this market sold for an average of 92.7 percent of their asking price over the past year, below the 96.4 percent median across the markets we publish.
This 4-bed single family in Georgian Bay (Baxter) is available now. Want me to connect you with the agent or keep you posted on any price updates?
Approximate location — exact address confirmed upon showing
This home lists at $2,700,777, about 30.7× the local median household income of $88,000.
Carrying it typically needs a household income of about $527,556 (20% down, 25-yr amortization, stress-tested) — roughly 499% above the area median.
Source: Statistics Canada, 2021 Census (FSA L0K)
Pick a time that suits you. A verified local agent confirms within 24h.
Loading rates, 30-yr amortization
Cash Needed to Close
Rates via our partner mortgage brokers at iShopRates · Estimates only, not financial advice




Estimate the monthly cashflow if you bought this home as a rental. Every figure below is an editable estimate. This is education only, not financial advice.
Enter the monthly rent you expect, or adjust our estimate.
Enter an estimated monthly rent to see the cashflow.
Estimates only, not a mortgage approval or financial advice. Rate, taxes, and allowances are assumptions you can edit above.
Room details as supplied by the listing brokerage. Dimensions are shown in the unit the listing states, and are approximate.